A Cinderella Story
2004's A Cinderella Story is a movie that ultra-permeated the consciousness of Hannah and Audrey's childhood. It's a true Moment for Hilary Duff's career— and a truly inexplicable one for the career of Jennifer Coolidge— but does it stand the test of time? Short answer... no. But listen to hear more.
Here's a link to the video essay Audrey refers to about Hilary Duff playing the same character in every movie— Yhara, the creator of the video, is one of Hannah and Audrey's absolute favorites and you should subscribe to her channel if you love their show!